Sentence (a) is a pseudo-passive. (31) c. Seoul can be walked around by his father. Finally, you'll never receive email notifications about content they create or likes they designate for your content.Note: if you proceed, you will no longer be following.We're sorry. A phrasal verb consists of a verb + an adverb (as complement).It is distinct from an intransitive verb that may be followed by {Preposition + NP = [adverbial] modifier}.The transitivity of a phrasal verb and its root verb often differ.I don't agree with the central proposition of the paper:English is peculiar in that it allows some of the prepositional verbs (multi-words consisting of a verb and a preposition) to be passivized.a. How to explain how this is wrong?When can verbal passives be used in secondary predicates?Unexpected goods delivery - is this a scam, and what kind of scam?Challenger Shuttle: could the crew have survived?Dipole moment of (1s,2s,3s)-1,2,3-trichlorocyclopropane.Do native speakers use the phrase "set channels"?Can the hydrogen bond angle of water be changed via distillation?A wizard is magically engineering the perfect agriculture animal that will replace as many farm animals as possible, what is he making?Does WiFi still work if I use my router as a switch?Does testing on Internet Explorer still make sense in 2020?Why is changing the size of the Supreme Court considered dangerous today, when it has been done in the past?Can a creature use legendary resistance to succeed against a scrying spell?Application form for lecturer position provides a template for an academic resume, should I follow that?How certain are we that we have not sent life to other planets/moons?How does a computer know which device is connected to the usb port?Why are options more popular than futures among retail investors?Why do oscilloscopes have such high sampling rates when the bandwidth is low?Why is power of a signal equal to square of that signal?TvöD contract E13 (limited contract 2 year) notice period.Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Impersonal passive voice, a grammatical form that deletes the subject of an intransitive verb; Prepositional passive, a form of English passive voice in which the object of a preposition becomes the subject of a clause; See also. Richard Nordquist is professor emeritus of rhetoric and English at Georgia Southern University and the author of several university-level grammar and composition textbooks.ThoughtCo uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. Without such context, I'd find.Is it correct that only transitive verbs can have passive form?California Department of Fish and Wildlife’s (CDFW) Data Portal,nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=51074,Goodbye, Prettify. Hello highlight.js! Pseudopassive or pseudo-passive may refer to: . . By using ThoughtCo, you accept our,Acceptable and Unacceptable Pseudo-Passives,Definitions and Examples of Passivization in English,Understanding the Types of Verbs in English Grammar,The Double Passive in English: Definition and Examples,Passive Voice Usage and Examples for ESL/EFL,Definition and Examples of Semantic Patients in Grammar,The Passive Voice in Italian: Another Way of Looking at Verbs,Ph.D., Rhetoric and English, University of Georgia,M.A., Modern English and American Literature, University of Leicester,B.A., English, State University of New York,"The high-priced concert-and-dinner tickets,"Gita felt that she no longer existed except as a sodden, aching huddle under the rock, waiting,"I came to the station meaning to tell you everything then. *The hotel was stayed in by my sister.b. (Compare "They talked (intransitive) for days .....{about (preposition) the scandal} ............................................................(adv. However, if these actions are performed by a particular individual such Since your assessment is not in line with that of the paper, I'd also need more evidence that (c) examples are as impossible as (a) examples.As for your two examples that you have cited, I find the first one acceptable because the "walking around" did affect the city whose walls fell down. About this particular kind of intransitive verb, Quirk et al. * explain "There is a pseudo-passive construction with intransitive verbs of motion or completion in which the participle is active rather than passive in meaning: Why are all those cars stopped at the corner? About this particular kind of intransitive verb, Quirk et al. *Seoul was walked around by his father. I'd say both sound less acceptable than the examples above with "walked around".The author is discussing phrasal verbs. So a pseudo passive (i.e., false passive) is not passive at all. (32) a. Sentence (a) is a pseudo-passive. I don't think it's just a matter of modals allowing a (pseudo)passive construction. mod.).b. About this particular kind of intransitive verb, Quirk et al. This paper aims to shed some light on two roughly synonymous grammatical constructions by means of collostructional analysis. So I think I'd need more evidence (than your own assessment) before I dismiss the paper's assessment of the examples. @JK2: The second citation is from a PDF document for which I only have a download link:Given the limited context, I suppose that the "walking around" in your second example doesn't merely refer to the act of walking around the lake but to the purposeful act of observing the lake for its fish population possibly followed by treating it by planting some kinds of fish such as rainbow trout, which does have some effect on the lake. the garden. mod.)...............(adv. The scandal was talked (passive) about (adverb) for days.Compare "To relax, he walked about(adv.)" I don't know of any theoretical reason why modals would be expected to have such an effect, and I would not classify 31c) or 32c) as acceptable sentences. Ambiguity in Pseudo-Passives "Some passive sentences are ambiguous, especially in the past tense, e.g.The job was finished at two o'clock.